All use cases
Marketing & Social

A leather goods maker's marketing agency published a "lifetime warranty" he doesn't offer, and ChatGPT repeated it to a customer

He paid $1,400 a month for blog posts he never read. A customer showed up with a ChatGPT screenshot quoting one of them.

Real storyDone with An outside marketing agency's blog posts (commenters believe they were AI-written; the poster doesn't say) + ChatGPT (on the customer's side)
TradesAll trades

What they did

The poster makes leather wallets and card holders in his garage and sells them on his own site, most items $60 to $120. He says a normal month is "around $13k in sales," with one part-time helper. In mid June he signed a six-month contract with a marketing company at $1,400 a month for eight blog posts a month and a monthly report. "They publish straight to my site and I never checked what went up."

How it went

A customer emailed asking for a replacement "under my lifetime warranty. We don't have one, it's two years. She sent a screenshot of ChatGPT saying we do," and one of the agency's blog posts "says the exact same thing." He then found another post about a brown color he stopped making in the spring. Visits are up, but he's "getting the same 150 or so orders a month I had before I signed." The agency offered to edit the posts and said the contract "covers writing and rankings, not sales." He's paid $5,600 so far with two months left. In the comments, several people guessed the posts were AI-written; one said "ChatGPT will make up things like a warranty in blog posts... I use ai generated content bit i read every word and inspect every fact." Others said to honor the one wallet, pull the agency's publishing access the same day, and post a plain warranty page. One warned that deleting the post "wont fix the chatgpt answer right away," because the old copy "can hang around for weeks," so ask Google and Bing to recrawl. A few commenters doubted the post was real, so treat the numbers as his own account.

Worth knowing

Whatever is on your website is what AI assistants tell your customers, including mistakes someone else wrote. Read every page that goes up under your name before it's live. Keep your warranty, service area, and prices on one plain page so a correct version exists. Fixing a page doesn't fix the AI answer overnight.

Try it yourself

You are a careful website editor and customer-policy checker for a small Wisconsin trade business. Your job is to find anything on my site that promises something I don't actually offer, before a customer or an AI assistant repeats it. TASK: Compare my website pages against my real policies. List every mismatch, then write one plain "Policies & Facts" page that states the truth. CONTEXT (fill in the [BRACKETS]): - [BUSINESS NAME + TRADE]: Example: Lac La Belle Plumbing & Drain (fictional), residential plumbing - [MY REAL POLICIES]: warranty terms, service area, hours, emergency fees, payment terms, what I don't do. Example: 1-year labor warranty; manufacturer warranty on fixtures; service area Oconomowoc, Delafield, Hartland, Pewaukee; $149 after-hours trip fee; no septic work - [PAGES TO CHECK]: paste the text of each page or blog post, with its URL. Example: /blog/water-heater-guide, /services, /about - [WHO WROTE THEM]: me, an agency, or AI. Example: an agency wrote the blog posts in 2026 STEPS: 1. Read [MY REAL POLICIES]. Make a short list of the facts that must never be wrong: warranty, prices or fees, service area, hours, services offered and not offered, brands, guarantees. 2. Go through [PAGES TO CHECK] one at a time. Quote every sentence that states or implies a warranty, guarantee, price, timeline, service area, product, or brand. 3. Mark each one MATCHES, WRONG, or NOT IN MY POLICIES. For WRONG, write the corrected sentence. 4. Flag any promise words: "lifetime," "guaranteed," "always," "same-day," "free," "best price." 5. Write a "Policies & Facts" page in plain language, under 400 words, using ONLY [MY REAL POLICIES]. 6. Write 5 questions a customer might ask ChatGPT about my business, with the correct short answer for each, so I can check what AI tools say. RULES: - Use only what's in [MY REAL POLICIES] and the pages I pasted. Never invent a policy. If something is unclear, write ASK OWNER. - Don't soften a wrong promise. Call it out plainly. - Keep my real warranty wording exact if I gave it. OUTPUT FORMAT: Part A: a mismatch table (page | quoted sentence | MATCHES / WRONG / NOT IN POLICIES | fix). Part B: the Policies & Facts page. Part C: 5 test questions with correct answers. Part D: a to-do list (unpublish, edit, recheck date). FOLLOW-UPS TO TRY NEXT: - "Write a 3-sentence reply to a customer who is asking for a warranty I don't offer, offering a one-time goodwill fix." - "Write a short approval rule for my marketing vendor: nothing goes live until I approve it." - "Turn the 5 test questions into a monthly checklist I can run in ChatGPT, Gemini and Google." FILLED-IN EXAMPLE (fictional Wisconsin business): - [BUSINESS NAME + TRADE] = Lac La Belle Plumbing & Drain (fictional), residential plumbing - [MY REAL POLICIES] = 1-year labor warranty; service area Oconomowoc, Delafield, Hartland, Pewaukee; $149 after-hours trip fee; no septic or well work - [PAGES TO CHECK] = an agency blog post that says "every install is backed by our lifetime guarantee" and "we serve all of Waukesha County" - [WHO WROTE THEM] = marketing agency, posted without my review
Open this prompt

Want help getting this working? Rise Systems in Oconomowoc sets these up.

Want this running in your business without the DIY? Rise Systems in Oconomowoc sets these up.

Free 15-minute AI check-up
Read the original

Source: Reddit · October 9, 2026

Related