All use cases
Phones & Booking

A contractor tried the AI phone answering built into his CRM. Callers got frustrated, and he turned it off

A thread asking whether an AI answering your phone beats a missed call drew more "no" than "yes" from contractors who'd been on either end.

Real storyDone with an AI phone answering feature built into a CRM (the CRM wasn't named)

What they did

In r/Contractor, u/Plastic-Goat2236 said he was "paying for ads and then missing like half the calls cause I'm on a ladder or under a house" and asked if anyone had actually tried an AI answering service. u/Burr32 had: "I used one for a while that was built into my CRM. I would get transcripts afterwards and people would get very frustrated with it."

How it went

"I don't use it anymore." Others in the thread: u/FinnTheDogg, who says he has LLMs heavily built into his business operations, said "nothing fucking fills me with rage more than AI voice trees," and wants "a human or ... a voice mail box." u/El_Eleventh uses Patlive (a human answering service) and said "people love it compared to an AI service." u/No-Scheme-9700 thought trust depends on how you present your company. Several replies came from AI-answering vendors and marketers, and some commenters suspected the original post was a setup for a pitch.

Worth knowing

The useful detail is that Burr32 read the transcripts, and that's how he knew callers were frustrated. If you try an AI answering tool, read a full week of transcripts before deciding, give callers an easy way to reach a person or leave a message, and compare against a human answering service. Treat glowing replies in threads like this with care, since many come from people selling the tools.

Try it yourself

You are a call-quality reviewer for a small Wisconsin contractor testing an AI phone answering tool. You read call transcripts and tell me honestly whether callers are being helped or getting frustrated. You don't change any settings. TASK: Review this week's AI-answered call transcripts and tell me if I should keep it, fix it, or turn it off. CONTEXT (fill in the [BRACKETS]): - [MY BUSINESS]: Example: (fictional) Pewaukee Lake Remodeling, kitchens and baths, 2 crews - [WHAT THE AI IS SUPPOSED TO DO]: Example: answer when I'm on a job, get name, number, address, job type, and text me a summary - [TRANSCRIPTS]: paste 7 days of transcripts or summaries - [WHAT A GOOD CALL LOOKS LIKE]: Example: caller gives details, gets told when I'll call back, hangs up calm - [MY BACKUP OPTION]: Example: voicemail, or a human answering service STEPS: 1. Sort every call: got what they needed / partly / frustrated / hung up / wanted a human. 2. For each frustrated or hung-up call, quote the exact line where it went wrong. 3. Count how many calls captured name, number, address and job type. 4. List the top 3 repeat problems (e.g. interrupts, loops, can't reach a person). 5. Say whether each problem is fixable with a setting or script change, or built into the tool. 6. Recommend keep / fix and retest for one week / switch to [MY BACKUP OPTION], with your reason. RULES: - Quote transcripts exactly; never invent caller words. - If a transcript is cut off or unclear, mark it UNCLEAR. - Count a caller asking for a person as a problem unless they got one or a clear callback time. OUTPUT FORMAT: Part A: call sort table. Part B: problem quotes. Part C: info-capture rate. Part D: top 3 problems + fixable? Part E: recommendation. FOLLOW-UPS TO TRY NEXT: - "Write a shorter greeting that says up front it's my assistant and offers a callback." - "Compare these results to a week of my voicemails. Which one lost fewer jobs?" - "Draft the questions I should ask a human answering service before I switch."
Open the full playbook

Want help getting this working? Rise Systems in Oconomowoc sets these up.

Want this running in your business without the DIY? Rise Systems in Oconomowoc sets these up.

Free 15-minute AI check-up
Read the original

Source: Reddit · October 27, 2026

Related
AU
Answer missed and after-hours calls (and book the job)

A complete after-hours call script and the instructions to paste into an AI receptionist (or give to an answering service).

Auto repairHVACPlumbingElectricalGarage doorsMediumPlaybook
Wisconsin Trades AI editorial·Oct 2026