A new residential contractor (magikarp-core) asked r/Contractor whether to pay for ChatGPT Plus. He uses free ChatGPT for estimates and questions, but "I don't use it to make an entire estimate, I use it to find information on current product prices and ask it questions for things I didn't think about," including building techniques on 1930s houses. "AI is cheaper than hiring someone." Other contractors replied with what it did to their bids.
How it went
KelseyRawr: "My customer fed her estimate to GPT, it told her we were overpriced. That customer was my aunt, and we had zero markup." It also told her she needed "Permits (her municipality did not require them), engineers report (again not required...)." Another commenter "pretended to be a customer to ask ChatGPT what it thought of my quotes. It claimed I was overpriced." Lateclap said "more and more of my homeowners are running their questions through AI before they ask me," and uses it himself to compare HVAC and window bids and research code questions. No_Line4262, a GC in Phoenix doing industrial work, foundations and shutdowns, has one rule: "it never gets to say a number I didn't give it. Ask it to price a job cold and it guesses, and it guesses low." He walks the job, talks into his phone, and it turns that into "a clean scope with the exclusions spelled out. That alone is worth the $20." On customers: "A line that says 'Concrete: $14,500' gets called overpriced. A line that says 4,000 psi, #4 rebar at 12" on center, pump truck, and haul-off of the old slab holds up."
Worth knowing
Assume your proposal will get pasted into a chatbot. Lump-sum lines lose that comparison and spelled-out specs win it. Don't let the AI pick your prices, because commenters say it guesses low. Say up front which permits and reports your town actually requires, so a chatbot's generic list doesn't cast doubt on you.
Try it yourself
You are a senior estimator who has watched homeowners paste proposals into ChatGPT and come back saying "it says you're overpriced." Your job is to make my proposal hold up to that check without changing my price.
TASK: Rewrite my proposal so every line shows what the customer is actually getting, then predict the pushback an AI chatbot would give and answer it.
CONTEXT (fill in the [BRACKETS]):
- [BUSINESS + TRADE]: Example: Ashippun Concrete & Flatwork (fictional)
- [MY PROPOSAL]: paste it as written, with my prices. Example: "Driveway replacement: $14,500"
- [SPECS I ACTUALLY USE]: materials, thickness, strength, reinforcement, equipment, prep, haul-off, cleanup. Example: 5" thick, 4,000 psi mix, #4 rebar 18" on center, 6" compacted base, pump truck, haul-off of old slab
- [LOCAL REQUIREMENTS]: what my town actually requires. Example: Village of Hartland driveway permit required; no engineer report for residential flatwork
- [WARRANTY + EXCLUSIONS]: Example: 2-year workmanship warranty; not responsible for salt damage; no sealing included
- [WHY MY PRICE IS WHAT IT IS]: crew pay, insurance, licensing, season. Example: licensed, insured, W-2 crew, 3-person crew
STEPS:
1. Break each lump-sum line into its parts using ONLY [SPECS I ACTUALLY USE]. Keep my totals exactly the same.
2. Add a "What's included / What's not" section from [WARRANTY + EXCLUSIONS].
3. Add a "Permits and requirements" line using ONLY [LOCAL REQUIREMENTS].
4. Write the 5 objections a chatbot is most likely to raise (overpriced, missing permit, needs an engineer, cheaper material, skip a step), and a calm, factual 2-sentence answer to each.
5. Flag any line that's still vague enough to be called overpriced.
RULES:
- Never change, lower or invent a price. Never invent a spec, code requirement or warranty. If something is missing, write NEEDED.
- Plain language a homeowner understands. Explain any trade term in a few words.
- Don't bash the customer or the AI. Stay factual.
OUTPUT FORMAT: Part A: the rewritten proposal with a line-item table (item | spec | qty | price). Part B: the 5 likely objections with answers. Part C: lines still too vague.
FOLLOW-UPS TO TRY NEXT:
- "Write a short text reply to a customer who says ChatGPT told them my bid is too high."
- "Make a good/better/best version using only the specs and prices I gave you."
- "Turn the 5 objections into a one-page FAQ I can attach to every proposal."
FILLED-IN EXAMPLE (fictional Wisconsin business):
- [BUSINESS + TRADE] = Ashippun Concrete & Flatwork (fictional)
- [MY PROPOSAL] = "Driveway tear-out and replace, 24x40: $14,500"
- [SPECS I ACTUALLY USE] = 5" thick, 4,000 psi air-entrained mix for freeze-thaw, #4 rebar 18" on center, 6" compacted base, pump truck, haul-off of the old slab
- [LOCAL REQUIREMENTS] = village driveway permit (we pull it); no engineer report needed
- [WARRANTY + EXCLUSIONS] = 2-year workmanship; sealing not included; no warranty on road-salt scaling