All use cases
Quotes & Estimates

Estimators say AI takeoff tools still need a human to check every count, and one says chatting his way to a proposal is slower

"9/10 times the slop comes up with something wrong." The tasks that did work: counting simple items, summarizing narratives, comparing drawing changes.

Real storyDone with Company-built AI takeoff tool (unnamed) + Perplexity

What they did

An r/estimators thread asked how the new AI estimating tools compare to Bluebeam, CostX and Cubit. J_Square83 said his company is "pushing an AI tool like this hard." It's proprietary and "developed specifically for us," and "higher ups insist" it's ready. SociallyDisposible used Perplexity "for some basic counting and square footages. Things like flooring and base when there are good finish plans," plus counting Division 10 items, summarizing design narratives and comparing drawing changes.

How it went

J_Square83: "It also winds up taking me longer to chat my way to a proposal than doing the work manually," and "when a scope review comes up, I get that deer in headlights sensation" he doesn't get on jobs he did by hand. SociallyDisposible found it "drains a ton of 'credits' and is kind of expensive for what it can do," but "much more useful" for summarizing narratives and comparing changes. Others: "very misleading unless you've already performed the takeoff and can fact check," "They only work for perfect prints, and even then have errors," and "really really useful for people who aren't liable when the numbers end up being wrong." One team is "letting it run alongside our team," and says cross-checking "seems to be increasing accuracy." Another commenter argued doing the takeoff yourself is how you "learn and understand the scope of the project."

Worth knowing

Today the safer uses are around the takeoff: summarizing specs and narratives, comparing drawing revisions, and counting obvious items on clean plans. Run AI next to your own takeoff and compare, and don't replace it yet. Watch the credit costs. You own the number either way.

Try it yourself

You are a chief estimator reviewing plan revisions for a small commercial subcontractor. You never produce quantities. You find what changed and what might be missing so a human estimator can check it. TASK: Compare two versions of the project documents and give me a change log and scope-gap list. No takeoff. CONTEXT (fill in the [BRACKETS]): - [COMPANY + SCOPE]: Example: Rock River Interiors (fictional), drywall, framing and ceilings - [PROJECT]: Example: medical office tenant build-out, Watertown, WI - [VERSION A]: paste the earlier spec sections, narrative or sheet notes (text). Example: Bid set, Sept 2026 - [VERSION B]: paste the newer version. Example: Addendum 2, Oct 2026 - [MY BID ASSUMPTIONS]: Example: Level 4 finish; 5/8" Type X at corridors; ACT by others - [SHEETS I'M RESPONSIBLE FOR]: Example: A-101 to A-501, RCP sheets, Division 09 specs STEPS: 1. List every change between [VERSION A] and [VERSION B] that touches my scope. Give the sheet or section, the old text, the new text, and the impact (adds, deletes, changes, unclear). 2. Compare the changes to [MY BID ASSUMPTIONS]. Flag every assumption that's now wrong or at risk. 3. List scope gaps: items mentioned in the narrative or specs that don't clearly appear on the sheets, or the other way around. 4. Draft RFI questions for anything unclear, one question per RFI, in plain language. 5. Give me a "re-check these quantities" list. Name the areas or items to re-measure, with NO numbers. RULES: - Never give or estimate a quantity, length, area or price. Write RE-MEASURE. - Quote the source text for every change. If you're not sure two passages match, say UNSURE. - Only use the text I pasted. Don't assume drawings you can't see. OUTPUT FORMAT: Part A: change log table (sheet/section | old | new | impact). Part B: assumptions at risk. Part C: scope gaps. Part D: draft RFIs. Part E: re-check list. FOLLOW-UPS TO TRY NEXT: - "Write a short qualifications and exclusions paragraph for my bid based on the at-risk assumptions." - "Summarize this 40-page spec section in 10 bullets that matter for my scope." - "Turn the RFI list into an email to the GC's project manager." FILLED-IN EXAMPLE (fictional Wisconsin business): - [COMPANY + SCOPE] = Rock River Interiors (fictional), drywall and ceilings - [PROJECT] = medical office build-out, Watertown, WI - [VERSION A] = bid-set Division 09 text; [VERSION B] = Addendum 2 text changing corridor walls to 1-hour rated and adding a soffit at reception - [MY BID ASSUMPTIONS] = Level 4 finish; corridors 5/8" Type X one layer
Open the full playbook

Want help getting this working? Rise Systems in Oconomowoc sets these up.

Want this running in your business without the DIY? Rise Systems in Oconomowoc sets these up.

Free 15-minute AI check-up
Read the original

Source: Reddit · October 14, 2026

Related
AU
Write estimates customers understand and approve

A clean estimate with a plain-English summary, a line-item table, what's not included, and how to approve.

Auto repairHVACPlumbingElectricalGarage doorsAuto bodyMediumPlaybook
Wisconsin Trades AI editorial·Oct 2026